Lesson 4
6 mins

Crafting Messages That Convert

Transform your messaging from generic broadcasts to personalized conversations. Learn behavior-first frameworks that drive action and see real-world examples that have delivered results.

Value first onboarding badge

Crafting Messages That Convert

Welcome back, messaging maestros! 🚀

Ever noticed how some Netflix recommendations feel like they're reading your mind, while others make you wonder if they've ever met you? That's the difference between messages that connect and ones that just add to the noise, especially when you're delivering those messages at scale. Today, we're learning how to be more Netflix, less spam.

Why Most Messages Fall Flat ✨

Think of user messages like conversations at a party. Nobody likes the person who only talks about themselves and never reads the room. Yet that's exactly what most product messages do:

The Common Culprits:

  • "Check out our new feature!" (Without context of user needs)
  • "Don't miss out!" (On something they've never shown interest in)
  • "Come back and try..." (Something they already use regularly)

"Your best message isn’t about your product — it’s really about your customer and how they could change for the better. If you approach your story from that point of view, you’re winning."

Emma Stratton
Founder,  Punchy

The Behavior-First Framework 🎯

Great messages start with understanding. Here's how to make every message count:

Number 1

Start With the Why

Instead of:

"Try our new template feature!"

Try:

"Need to create that quarterly report again? Our new templates can save you 2 hours."

Number 1

Match the Moment

Instead of:

"Upgrade your plan today!"

Try:

"Looks like you've used 90% of your storage. Ready to level up?"

Number 1

Keep It Action-Focused

Instead of:

"Our latest update includes improved collaboration features."

Try:

"Invite your team in one click and start collaborating today."

Real-World Success: How Top Companies Do It Right

ProfitWell’s focus on early value

ProfitWell analyzed retention patterns and found that users who saw value within the first week were significantly more likely to stick around. They reworked onboarding to spotlight key outcomes earlier. Read the full story →

Free-to-paid conversion equation

The result:

Number 1

20% increase in first-week retention

Accelo’s focus on contextual help

Accelo wanted to scale support without overwhelming their team, so they used behavior-based prompts to guide users at the right moment—like surfacing help docs and walkthroughs when users explored key features. Read the full story →

Free-to-paid conversion equation

The result:

Number 1

48% increase in feature activation and 84% of users rated the guidance helpful

Foresyte’s onboarding nudges

Foresyte introduced lightweight guidance during onboarding to explain features at just the right moment, helping new users take meaningful action early. Read the full story →

Free-to-paid conversion equation

The result:

Number 1

15% increase in onboarding success rate

Message Writing Pro Tips

Number 1

Write like a human being*

Number 2

Lead with the benefit

Number 2

Focus on one action

Number 2

Use behavior as context

*Even at scale, your messages should feel personal and relevant!

QUICK EXERCISE

Adding Message Content to Your Journey Map

Now let's enhance your Journey Map with effective message content:

Number 1


For 3-5 key touchpoints on your map:

Number 1

Draft message content using the behavior-first framework

Number 1

Focus on the specific value/outcome for the user at that moment

Number 1

Keep messages short, clear, and action-oriented

Number 1

Note these message examples directly in your Journey Map

Number 1


Review your message sequence:

Number 1

Check for consistency in tone and terminology

Number 1

Ensure each message builds on previous context

Number 1

Verify that calls-to-action are clear and appropriate

This message content layer transforms your map from a strategic outline to an actionable communication plan. In the next lesson, we'll connect these messages into cohesive flows.

The Perfect Message Checklist ✅

Before hitting send, ask:

Number 1

Is this triggered by actual user behavior?

Number 1

Does it acknowledge their context?

Number 1

Is the value clear immediately?

Number 1

Is there one clear action?

Number 1

Could this be shorter?

Number 1

Is it working in concert with other touchpoints?

Common Message Mistakes ⚠️

  • Focusing on features over benefits
  • Ignoring user context
  • Being too clever
  • Burying the action
  • Writing for yourself, not your user

Channel-Specific Tips with Real-World Examples

Number 1

In-App Messages

  • Keep it brief
  • Use visual hierarchy
  • Make actions obvious
  • Consider the user's task

Example in action:

To drive feature adoption, Zywave added a contextual nudge with clear instructions to help users connect with their carriers. It achieved an 88% success rate. Read their story →

Number 1

Email

  • Strong subject lines
  • Clear preview text
  • Scannable content
  • Single focus

Example in action:

When composing product launch emails, Grammarly opts to keep it tight (just three sentences!) and showcases the new feature with an informative illustration against a bold background, making it easy for the reader to digest and act. See more examples →

Free-to-paid conversion equation
Number 1

Push Notifications

  • Front-load important info
  • Create urgency (when real)
  • Make value clear instantly
  • Use social proof wisely

Example in action:

Spotify offers a quintessential push experience. They’ve perfected the art of leveraging user data to provide a hyper-personalized experience that creates urgency and leads users directly to value. See more examples in our Mobile Onboarding 101 course →

Free-to-paid conversion equation

Remember ✨

Great messages feel less like broadcasts and more like conversations. They show users you understand their needs and have something valuable to offer.

Key Takeaways

Number 1


Start with user behavior

Number 1


Focus on outcomes

Number 1


Keep it human

Number 1


Make action easy

Next up: We'll learn how to string these messages together into powerful flows. See you in Lesson 5! 🎯